Syria's Assad, an American hero? One Virginia politician thinks so. -  CSMonitor.com
Syrians in Lebanon hold portrait of leader Bashar al-Assad as they head to the polls to vote for him in May 2014 elections; Assad won with 88% of the vote. [Source: csmonitor.com]

United States warmakers have become so skilled at propaganda that not only can they wage a war of aggression without arousing protest; they can also compel liberals to denounce peace activists using language reminiscent of the McCarthy era.

Take the case of Syria. The people and groups one would normally count on to oppose wars have been the ones largely defending it. They have also often been the ones to label war opponents as “Assad apologists” or “genocide deniers”—causing them to be blacklisted.

A protest against the U.S. launching of missiles into Syria on Friday, April 7, 2017, near the Martin Luther King Jr. statue in Newark.
Protest against bombing of Syria in Newark, New Jersey, in April 2017. Most protests against the war in Syria have been small like this, and protesters have been susceptible to ridicule as Assad lovers or apologists. [Source: Northjersey.com]

Τον Απρίλιο, Το Έθνος magazine published an essay by Gilbert Achcar, a professor of international relations at the University of London entitled “How to Avoid the Anti-Imperialism of Fools.” Achcar is co-author with Noam Chomsky of a book critical of U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East,

Σε του Έθνος essay, he divides the Left into two factions—one which “opposes all forms of imperialism and oppression,” and one which “supports any regime or force that is the object of Washington’s hostility.” The latter includes “Russia’s thuggish capitalist and imperialist government, or Iran’s theocratic regime or the likes of Slobodan Milošević and Saddam Hussein.”[1]

The binary Achcar paints is misleading because it does not take into account war critics’ attempts to present more nuanced portraits of American targets for regime change like Putin or Milošević or even Hussein that would account for their domestic popularity. Nor the value placed on the principle of national self-determination and sovereignty, and identification of the double standards of U.S. human rights concerns.

Gilbert Achcar SOAS
Gilbert Achcar speaking at the University of London in 2012. [Source: thegrayzone.com]

Achcar supports military intervention in Syria under the UN doctrine of Responsibility to Protect (R2P), which enables foreign military intervention if it will stop large-scale human rights abuses.

He quotes favorably in his Έθνος article from a 2019 δήλωση signed by several prominent figures on the American Left—including Judith Butler, Noam Chomsky, the late David Graeber and David Harvey—demanding that the United States “continue military support for the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Force,” in the face of Donald Trump’s announced withdrawal.

This position was based on fear that if the U.S. withdrew, the Kurds would be slaughtered by Turkey, the Islamic State in the Levant (ISIS) or the “murderous Assad regime,” as Achcar termed it.

The Kurds, however, were being used as a proxy force by the U.S. in a regime-change operation that would enable foreign exploitation of Syria’s oil and military domination of the Middle East—and would inevitably be abandoned.

Western empires had used the pretext of human rights many times before to justify colonization, and recruited disaffected minority groups, which was no different in this case.

In Pictures: Syrians scour refuse dump for survival | Syria | Al Jazeera
A reminder of what the war is all about: A child sifts through a rubbish dump near an oil field in the countryside of al-Malikiya in northeast Syria. [Source: aljazeera.com]

Voices from Syria

Mark Taliano and Basma Qaddour’s book, Voices from Syria—now out in its second edition—offers a strong rebuttal to Achcar and others who consider opponents of U.S. military intervention in Syria to be foolish.

Voices from Syria: Revised Second Edition by [Mark Taliano, Basma Qaddour]
[Πηγή: amazon.com]

The authors—one a Montreal based teacher, the other a Syrian journalist—point out that the majority of Syrians consider Assad an authentic nationalist who has saved Syria from jihadist terrorists sponsored by the U.S., NATO, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Israel and Gulf Arab states like Qatar.

The terrorists have killed an estimated 150,000 civilians and another 260,000 fighters and kidnapped thousands more, some of whom were used for illegal organ harvesting.

Their goal is to impose a theocratic regime and to divide, plunder and exploit Syria and open it up to predatory foreign corporations.

Taliano and Qaddour write that “Syria’s stand against the Western agencies of death and destruction is a stand for all humanity against the dark forces that fester beneath our politicians’ empty words and the courtesan media’s toxic lies.”

These lies have ensured that few in the U.S. or West have acknowledged Syria’s heroic victory against colonial aggression—a modern-day equivalent to Vietnam’s victory over the French at the Battle of Dien Bien Phu in 1954.

Aleppo battle: Syrian city 'back under government control' - BBC News
Parade after Syrian Arab army liberated Aleppo from jihadist extremists backed by the West in 2016. [Source: bbc.com]

Long-Standing Plan for Regime Change

Two weeks after the September 11th attacks, General Wesley Clark was visited by a senior general who told him that the U.S. was going to attack Iraq: “The decision has basically been made.”

Six weeks later, when Clark returned to Washington to visit the same general and asked whether the plans for invading Iraq were still in place, the general responded, “‘Oh, it’s worse than that,’ he said, holding up a memo on his desk. ‘Here’s the paper from the Office of the Secretary of Defense [then Donald Rumsfeld] outlining the strategy. We’re going to take out seven countries in five years.’ And he named them, ξεκινώντας with Iraq and Syria and ending with Iran.”

Rumsfeld: Looting is transition to freedom - UPI.com
Donald Rumsfeld advanced a blueprint for toppling seven governments in the Middle East in five years. [Source: upi.com]

The key to the success of these latter operations was to convince the U.S. public that wars of aggression were military interventions carried out for humanitarian purposes. The way to do that was to give off the illusion that the targeted leaders were brutal dictators intent on waging a campaign of genocide against their own people.

Assad’s Accomplishments

Hafez al-Assad | Biography, Facts, Religion, & Son | Britannica
Hafez al-Assad, Bashar al-Assad’s father. [Source: britannica.com]

Syria was a main target on Rumsfeld’s list because its leader, Bashar al-Assad, was a secular nationalist like Saddam Hussein and Muammar Qaddafi of Libya, who was defiant of the West.

In 2000, Bashar succeeded his father Hafez al-Assad, who had long been a thorn in the side of the West. He had allied Syria with the Soviet Union during the Cold War, and in 1971 allowed the Russians to establish a naval base at Tartus.

H I Sutton - Covert Shores
[Πηγή: hisutton.com]

Though vilified in the West, Bashar retains support of the majority of Syrians because he has advanced free health care and education for Syrians and retained Syrian control over most of its economy while rallying the people against foreign aggression.

10733931_770903576314025_8801322907606464194_o
Syrian city of Aleppo before and after U.S.-backed war of aggression on Syria. [Source: petapixel.com]

While certainly there are brutal aspects to his rule like with his father, Assad’s accomplishments before the war, according to Taliano and Qaddour, included: a) construction and restoration of 10,000 mosques and 500 churches; b) construction of 8,000 schools; and c) construction of 600,000 apartment units for young people and 6,000 hospitals and clinics.

Μια ομάδα ανθρώπων που ποζάρουν για μια φωτογραφία Η περιγραφή δημιουργείται αυτόματα με μέτρια εμπιστοσύνη
Assad family in 1980s. Hafez in lower right and Bashar on left. [Source: newrepublic.com]

Further, salaries increased by 300 percent under Assad’s rule, thousands of new businesses sprung up, agricultural and industrial capacity increased, the illiteracy rate was kept low, and the unemployment rate declined from 28 to 12 percent.

Pro-Assad demonstration
Pro-Assad supporters at demonstration. Polls showed that Assad enjoyed the support of at least 55 percent of the Syrian population, a higher total than recent U.S. Presidents. [Source: theguardian.com]

These facts are at odds with the depiction of Assad as a genocidal tyrant.

The latter is part of a demonization campaign initiated by intelligence agencies and embraced by factions of the Left that have unwittingly helped to advance the agenda of the U.S. empire.

syria votes in an election result whose result is a foregone conclusion  assad will win - The Washington Post
Assad and his wife Asma voting in recent election that he won decisively. [Source: thewashingtonpost.com]
[Πηγή: nytimes.com]

“Your Obama Leading Proxy War”

In March 2011, Americans were led to believe that idealistic pro-democracy demonstrations erupted in the southern city of Daraa—inspired by Arab Spring protests in Egypt and Tunisia, and following an incident of police brutality.

Seven police were killed by the demonstrators in the very first protests, and 60 security forces were massacred two weeks later. The plan of the mob was to provoke a police response that would make it seem like the security forces were reacting harshly, which would discredit Assad’s regime.

At least 37 people have died in violent protests since last week in Daraa, the U.N says.
Protests in Daraa in March 2011. Note one of the supposedly peaceful demonstrators brandishing a knife. [Source: έκδοση.cnn.com]

For the first three weeks, police and security personnel were under orders, though, not to carry guns.

As the protests spread, foreign terrorists began descending on Syria and were paid $300-$400 per month. Although Syrian soldiers were paid only one-tenth of that amount, they remained mostly loyal to the Syrian government.

Majd al-Zaim, a Syrian, stated that what had happened in Syria was “not a revolution or civil war [as has been depicted in the Western media]. The terrorists are sent by your government [the U.S.]. They are Al-Qaeda, Jabhat al-Nusra, Wahhabi, Salafist, Talibans and the extremist jihadists are sent by the West, Saudis, Qataris, Turkey…. Your Obama and whoever is behind him or above him are supporting Al-Qaeda and leading a proxy war on my country.”

Syria Will Stain Obama's Legacy Forever – Foreign Policy
Barack Obama ordered the CIA’s largest covert operation since Afghanistan in the 1980s which destroyed Syria. Somehow he remains a revered figure in liberal circles. [Source: Foreignpolicy.com]

Ιστορικό υπόβαθρο

Historically, Syria faced divisions between secular nationalist and Shia Alawites and Sunni fundamentalists who allied with the Muslim Brotherhood.

In 1982, Hafez al-Assad crushed an Islamic rebellion (the Hama massacre), foreshadowing his son’s actions 30 years later.

A picture containing outdoor, ground, old, factory

Description automatically generated
A scene from Hama after the 1982 massacre. [Source: pbs.org]

A July 1986 declassified CIA document outlined a U.S. strategy in Syria that was hostile to Assad—as it remains. The document stated that “In our view, U.S. interests would be best served by a Sunni regime controlled by business-oriented moderates. Business moderates would see a strong need for Western aid and investment to build Syria’s private economy, thus opening the way for stronger ties to Western governments.”

The report acknowledged that the collapse of the Ba’athist state presided over by Assad could help to empower “religious zealots” seeking to establish “an Islamic Republic.”  But this was a risk that Washington was willing to take.

Twenty years later, the Chargé D’affaires at the U.S. embassy in Damascus, William Roebuck, in a leaked diplomatic cable, referred to the threat to the Assad regime from Islamic extremists as “an opportunity that the U.S. should take action to try to increase.”

William Roebuck: There has to be a solution in Syria in the coming period
William Roebuck [Source: fresh-syria.net]

Roebuck also pushed for better coordination with Egypt and Saudi Arabia in provoking sectarian divisions by exaggerating Iranian influence μαζί με ένα rumor campaign against Assad, and arming of the Kurds as part of a destabilization strategy, which was implemented under Obama.

An Inhuman Enemy

Voices from Syria tells the stories of the victims of U.S. policy like Ammar, whose sister was killed by a Wahhabi suicide bomber while she was on her way to the local university.

Ammar said that, after the first blast, another suicide bomber blew himself up in the same place, taking advantage of the gathering of people and ambulance teams. At the hospital, Ammar saw many burned and charred bodies, including his sister, who was now a “body without a soul”—like so many others.

Lilly Martin, an American living in Syria, is quoted in Voices from Syria as stating that she could not vote for Hillary Clinton in the 2016 election because Clinton had overseen “the transfer of weapons from Libya to Turkey to be used specifically by the American-backed terrorists.”

These terrorists destroyed Martin’s home on March 21, 2014, beheaded her Christian neighbors and kidnapped and raped the old ladies.

Lilly Martin on Muck Rack
Lilly Martin [Source: muckrack.com]

Dr. Declan Hayes described an attack by al-Nusra (U.S.-backed jihadi group) on the village of Kesab where the terrorists swarmed across the border on motorbikes, pick-up trucks, and Western ambulances, and proceeded to desecrate all of Kesab’s churches, loot the village graves and strip the houses of anything of value.

Pepken Djourian and his wife saw their only son executed in front of them, after which his body was left to rot in the sun before being thrown into the ground like a dog.

In another case, terrorists beheaded and executed a captured soldier while he was speaking to his father on the phone so he could hear his son being killed.

The terrorists further roasted bakery workers in a town loyal to Assad in an oven and slaughtered staff at a medical clinic and displayed their severed heads in the marketplace for intimidation.

Λειτουργία Timber Sycamore

Some of the head choppers were trained by U.S. military advisers at terrorist training camps in Jordan under the CIA’s $1 billion Operation Sycamore, the largest covert operation since the arming of the mujahadin fighters in Afghanistan to fight the Soviet Union in the 1980s.

Μια εικόνα που περιέχει πρόσωπο, εξωτερικό χώρο, ουρανό, στρατιωτική στολή Περιγραφή δημιουργήθηκε αυτόματα
A trainee with the Pentagon-backed Syrian Democratic Forces learns how to use his AK-47-style rifle at a secret training camp in Jordan. [Source: balkaninsight.com]

Turkish helicopters could be seen overhead during armed terrorist invasions of towns while the Syrian Arab Army was fighting insurgents who wore Turkish military uniforms and carried Turkish military identification.

The Israelis allowed Al Qaeda militants, Jabhat al-Nusra, to use the occupied Golan Heights to fight against the Syrian Army, while the Israeli Air Force repeatedly bombed Syria.

Israel Bombs Syria | Indus News | Indus News Bulletin - YouTube
[Πηγή: youtube.com]

Russia to the Rescue

In “How to Avoid the Anti-Imperialism of Fools,” Gilbert Achcar criticized U.S. and British- based anti-war groups for failing to condemn Russian imperialism in Syria.

Many Syrians, however, laud the Russians for helping to save their country.

Ammar told Taliano and Qaddour that “the Russians provided the biggest humanitarian aid by supporting the Syrian Armed Forces against Western backed barbarian terrorism,” and that Russian aid—including food and medical supplies—was distributed directly to needy people.

According to Russia's defence ministry, 92 Russian soldiers have been killed in Syria since September 2015 [File: Omar Sanadiki/Reuters]
Russian troops in Deir ez-Zor province amidst backdrop of photos of President Vladimir Putin and Bashar al-Assad. [Source: Aljazeera.com]

Lilly Martin stated that Russia had “saved the Syrian Coast”—along with Syrian towns like Kesab that were on the verge of destruction by the CIA-backed terrorists.

Cruel Economic War

The cruelty of Western policy is exemplified by its economic war on Syria, about which Achcar and his associates have been silent.

The goal of the economic war has been to weaken Syria and demoralize its people so as to pave the way for Syria’s conquest.

Militias affiliated with both the U.S. and Turkey blocked the sale by Syrian peasants of wheat and barley east of the Euphrates, thus exacerbating the food shortage in the country.

They have sold oil illegally in northern Iraq and set fires in an attempt to decimate Syria’s yield of strategic crops. Many of the fires have targeted olive trees, which are used to produce olive oil—a source of livelihood for many Syrians.

Άνθρωποι μάχονται με την πυρκαγιά σε γεωργικό χωράφι, στην επαρχία Χασάκε, κοντά στα σύνορα Συρίας-Τουρκίας
Άνθρωποι μάχονται με την πυρκαγιά σε γεωργικό χωράφι, στην επαρχία Αλ-Χασάκα, κοντά στα σύνορα Συρίας-Τουρκίας. [Πηγή: theguardian.com]

The economic sanctions have further prevented needed medical supplies and equipment from getting into Syria and caused milk shortages resulting in the deaths of children.

Fraudulent Pretexts

These sanctions have been legitimated by false propaganda.

The Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act, which was signed into law in December 2019 by President Donald Trump, was named after a government defector, Caesar, who leaked thousands of photographs alleging torture of civilians by Assad’s security forces.

The Caesar Photo Fraud that Undermined Syrian Negotiations. « A Pattern of  Sensational but Untrue Reports that Lead to Public Acceptance of Western  Military Intervention » | Mondialisation.ca
CNN show discussing Caesar’s “torture” report that was a basis for extending sanctions. [Source: mondialisation.ca]

Nearly half the photos Στην πραγματικότητα έδειχναν κυβερνητικούς στρατιώτες που είχαν σκοτωθεί και θύματα βομβών αυτοκινήτων και άλλης βίας που σχετίζεται με τον πόλεμο, και πολλοί άλλοι έδειχναν στρατιώτες που είχαν πεθάνει στη μάχη - όχι κυβερνητικά κέντρα βασανιστηρίων.

Η ταυτότητα του Καίσαρα ήταν επίσης ασαφής και υποπτευόταν ότι ήταν υπάλληλος της CIA.

More Bright Shining Lies

American-educated opinion about the Syria conflict has been forged by numerous other deceptions.

These include allegations of chemical weapons attacks by Assad—which most Syrians believe were “staged by the terrorists helped by the USA and UK.”

Another deception surrounds the White Helmets—a group of Western-funded humanitarian aid workers that received endorsement from A-list celebrities like George Clooney.

Financed in part by the United States Agency of International Development (USAID), the White Helmets were led by a suspected British MI6 agent, James Le Mesurier, who died under suspicious circumstances in November 2019.

The MSM can try rewriting the dubious history of White Helmets’ founder James Le Mesurier, but the truth is there for all to see
James Le Mesurier, who led the White Helmets, was a suspected British MI6 agent who died under suspicious circumstances in November 2019. [Source: rt.com]

They staged scenes for public relations purposes, assisted in public executions, and functioned as an Al Qaeda affiliate, according to Taliano and Qaddour, which occupied and destroyed more than 7,000 schools.

Syrian civil defense volunteers, known as the White Helmets, carry a body after digging it out from under the rubble of a building following a reported airstrike in the northern city of Aleppo on July 23, 2016.
Members of White Helmets assisting victims of bombing attack. [Source: theintercept.com]

The War on Terror Is a Fraud

The Syrian War exemplifies that the War on Terror is a fraud.

The U.S. government has claimed for the last two decades to be fighting the scourge of terrorism, but has armed, trained, and supported Islamic terrorists in Syria as part of an imperial strategy designed to control the country’s oil wealth and dominate the entire region.

Another motive is to provoke destabilization so as to justify endless war—which brings huge profits to war industries that fund both major political parties.

U.S. policy in Syria is no anomaly as the U.S. has supported Islamic fundamentalists in Libya, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Chechnya, Azerbaijan, Turkey, and Gulf Arab states like Qatar, which allows terrorist financiers to operate in its borders.

Only a very limited number of Americans have recognized the dangers of this strategy—owing in large part to the sophisticated propaganda that has effectively brainwashed many of those who would traditionally identify themselves as antiwar.


  1. Declassified British documents obtained by Το έργο Grayzone showed that Achcar trained British Cultural Defense Units who played a key role in the British war in Afghanistan. The Units have also advised the military on how to operate in other countries, including those that were at one time colonized by Great Britain. See Ben Norton, “Elite UK military unit secretly trained by leftist regime-change advocate Gibert Achcar and other academics,” Το έργο Grayzone, October 3, 2019, https://thegrayzone.com/2019/10/03/leftist-regime-change-activist-gilbert-achcar-academics-train-uk-military/


Περιοδικό CovertAction καθίσταται δυνατή από συνδρομέςπαραγγελιών και δωρεές από αναγνώστες όπως εσείς.

Σφυρίξτε τον ιμπεριαλισμό των ΗΠΑ

 

 

Κάντε κλικ στο σφύριγμα και δώστε

 

Όταν δωρίζετε σε Περιοδικό CovertActionυποστηρίζετε την ερευνητική δημοσιογραφία. Οι συνεισφορές σας απευθύνονται άμεσα στην υποστήριξη της ανάπτυξης, παραγωγής, επεξεργασίας και διάδοσης του περιοδικού.

Περιοδικό CovertAction δεν λαμβάνει εταιρική ή κυβερνητική χορηγία. Ωστόσο, έχουμε σταθερή δέσμευση για παροχή αποζημίωσης για συγγραφείς, συντακτική και τεχνική υποστήριξη. Η υποστήριξή σας βοηθά στη διευκόλυνση αυτής της αποζημίωσης καθώς και στην αύξηση του επιπέδου αυτής της εργασίας.

Κάντε μια δωρεά κάνοντας κλικ στο λογότυπο δωρεάς παραπάνω και εισαγάγετε το ποσό και τα στοιχεία της πιστωτικής ή χρεωστικής κάρτας σας.

Το CovertAction Institute, Inc. (CAI) είναι ένας μη κερδοσκοπικός οργανισμός 501(c)(3) και το δώρο σας εκπίπτει φορολογικά για λόγους ομοσπονδιακού εισοδήματος. Ο αφορολόγητος αριθμός αναγνωριστικού της CAI είναι 87-2461683.

Σας ευχαριστούμε ειλικρινά για την υποστήριξή σας.


Αποποίηση ευθυνών: Τα περιεχόμενα αυτού του άρθρου αποτελούν αποκλειστική ευθύνη του/των συγγραφέα/ών. CovertAction Institute, Inc. (CAI), συμπεριλαμβανομένου του Διοικητικού Συμβουλίου του (BD), του Editorial Board (EB), του Advisory Board (AB), του προσωπικού, των εθελοντών και των έργων του (συμπεριλαμβανομένων Περιοδικό CovertAction) δεν φέρουν καμία ευθύνη για ανακριβή ή λανθασμένη δήλωση σε αυτό το άρθρο. Αυτό το άρθρο επίσης δεν αντιπροσωπεύει απαραίτητα τις απόψεις του BD, του EB, του AB, του προσωπικού, των εθελοντών ή των μελών των έργων του.

Διαφορετικές απόψεις: Η CAM δημοσιεύει άρθρα με διαφορετικές απόψεις σε μια προσπάθεια να καλλιεργήσει έντονη συζήτηση και προσεκτική κριτική ανάλυση. Μη διστάσετε να σχολιάσετε τα άρθρα στην ενότητα σχολίων ή / και να στείλετε τις επιστολές σας στο Συντάκτες, το οποίο θα δημοσιεύσουμε στη στήλη Γράμματα.

Υλικό που προστατεύεται από πνευματικά δικαιώματα: Αυτός ο ιστότοπος ενδέχεται να περιέχει υλικό που προστατεύεται από πνευματικά δικαιώματα, του οποίου η χρήση δεν έχει πάντα εγκριθεί ειδικά από τον κάτοχο των πνευματικών δικαιωμάτων. Ως μη κερδοσκοπικός φιλανθρωπικός οργανισμός που έχει συσταθεί στην Πολιτεία της Νέας Υόρκης, διαθέτουμε τέτοιο υλικό σε μια προσπάθεια να προωθήσουμε την κατανόηση των προβλημάτων της ανθρωπότητας και ελπίζουμε να βοηθήσουμε στην εξεύρεση λύσεων για αυτά τα προβλήματα. Πιστεύουμε ότι αυτό αποτελεί «ορθή χρήση» οποιουδήποτε υλικού που προστατεύεται από πνευματικά δικαιώματα, όπως προβλέπεται στην ενότητα 107 του νόμου περί πνευματικών δικαιωμάτων των ΗΠΑ. Μπορείτε να διαβάσετε περισσότερα για «ορθή χρήση» και ο νόμος περί πνευματικών δικαιωμάτων των ΗΠΑ στο Νομικό Ινστιτούτο Νομικής Σχολής του Cornell.

Αναδημοσίευση: Περιοδικό CovertAction (CAM) χορηγεί άδεια για διασταύρωση άρθρων CAM σε μη κερδοσκοπικούς ιστότοπους κοινότητας στο Διαδίκτυο, εφόσον η πηγή αναγνωρίζεται μαζί με έναν υπερσύνδεσμο προς το πρωτότυπο Περιοδικό CovertAction άρθρο. Επίσης, παρακαλούμε ενημερώστε μας στο info@CovertActionMagazine.com. Για δημοσίευση άρθρων CAM σε έντυπη μορφή ή άλλες μορφές, συμπεριλαμβανομένων εμπορικών ιστότοπων στο Διαδίκτυο, επικοινωνήστε με: info@CovertActionMagazine.com.

Χρησιμοποιώντας αυτόν τον ιστότοπο, αποδέχεστε τους παραπάνω όρους.


Σχετικά με το Συγγραφέας

40 ΣΧΟΛΙΑ

    • The author appears to be answering the question from yourself and Michael by sending 2 videos from Carlton Meyer. I am not very knowledgeable about this topic, so you and Michael can watch and formulate your opinions on these videos.

  1. I tried reading the essay by Gilbert Achcar but I found it very difficult to understand as I am not an acedemic intellectual type. The only thing that I understood was the first line which said “The logic of “the enemy of my enemy is my friend” is a recipe for empty cynicism”

    I also find the logic that the enemy of my enemy is my friend to be a questionable way of thinking.

  2. [Gilbert Achcar] quotes favorably in his Nation article from a 2019 statement signed by several prominent figures on the American Left—including Judith Butler, Noam Chomsky, the late David Graeber and David Harvey—demanding that the United States “continue military support for the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Force,” in the face of Donald Trump’s announced withdrawal.

    First, The Nation became a Democratic Party mouthpiece quite a while ago. Second, I fear that Chomsky, also a Democratic Party supporter (which means a supporter of war criminals), has deteriorated into dementia. Judith Butler is a creepy academic with no understanding of radical feminism who makes false pronouncements about it. And I am very disturbed by David Graeber and David Harvey’s participation in this. But academia is not known for its deep connections to the real world where real people live and work and where real wars destroy humans and their environment. As far as I am concerned, anyone, no matter their previous respectability, who supports U.S. military intervention is utterly without conscience.

    It is not your responsibility, Michael, to decide what is good for Syria. Take a glance at your own disgusting, bankrupt, corrupt nation which engages in human rights abuses every minute of every day of every year.

  3. Wonderful article and long overdue. The current four horsemen of the Apocalypse, The U.S. Israel, Britain, and Saudi Arabia have caused the deaths of millions of innocents with their insane policies. Unfortunately, most destruction and political nonsense in the Middle East is done at the behest of Israel. Israel’s Oded Yinon Plan or Greater Israel project see’s it’s borders on the Nile and the Euphrates with great amounts of land taken from it’s neighbors. It truly is a pipe-dream, but, they still try to achieve it no matter who or how many suffer in the process. And, America protects these thugs!

  4. But see Assad or We Burn the Country: How One Family’s Lust for Power Destroyed Syria. Among other things it offers a very detailed discussion of exactly how U.S. intelligence concluded that Syria was responsibility for the chemical attacks to which the U.S. responded, as opposed to this article’s blithe generalization that “most Syrians believe were “staged by the terrorists helped by the USA and UK.” One wonders how the opinions of “most” Syrians were ascertained.

Αφήστε μια απάντηση