The author with Pyatnashka commanders at outpost near Avdeevka, Donetsk People’s Republic. [Source: Photo courtesy of Eva Bartlett]

America is widely understood to be a key instigator behind conflict in Ukraine that has pitted brother against brother

Smeared, stigmatized, and lied about in Western media propaganda, the mostly Russian-speaking people of the Donbass region were being slaughtered by the thousands in a brutal war of “ethnic cleansing” launched against them by the neo-Nazi regime in Kyiv, which the U.S. installed after the CIA overthrew Ukraine’s legally elected president in a 2014 coup.

Although the Donbass people had been pleading for Russian military aid to defend them against the increasingly murderous military assaults by the Ukraine government forces, which killed more than 14,000 of their people, Russian President Vladimir Putin declined to intervene. Instead, he tried to broker a peace agreement between the warring parties.

But the U.S. and Britain secretly colluded to sabotage peace negotiations, persuading president Zelenksy to ignore the Minsk III peace agreement that the Ukraine government had previously signed, and which had been countersigned by Russia, France and Germany.

Realizing that the U.S. and its NATO allies would never permit peace negotiations to succeed, Putin finally sent troops into Ukraine on February 24. Russian troops went in to support and reinforce the outnumbered and outgunned Donbass Special Forces who had been defending their land against attacks by the Kyiv government for nearly eight years.

Voices From the Frontlines of Former Eastern Ukraine Republics

In the Donetsk People’s Republic (DPR) in October, I went to a frontline outpost 70 meters from Ukrainian forces in Avdeevka (north and west of Donetsk), according to the Donbas commanders I spoke with there.

To reach that position, I went with two other journalists to a meeting point with two commanders of Pyatnashka—volunteer fighters, including Abkhazi, Slovak, Russian, Ossetian and other nationalities, including locals from Donbas.

From there, they drove us to a point as far as they could drive before walking the rest of the way, several minutes through brush and trenches, eventually coming to their sandbagged wood and cement fortified outpost.

It has changed hands over the years, Ukrainian forces sometimes occupying it, Donbas forces now controlling it.

One soldier, a unit commander who goes by the call sign “Vydra” (Otter), was formerly a miner from the DPR who had been living in Russia with his family. In 2014, he returned to the Donbas to defend his mother and relatives still there. He spoke of the outpost.

“We dug and built this with our hands. Several times over the years, the Ukrainians have taken these positions. We pushed them back, they stormed us…Well, we have been fighting each other for eight years.”

There, artillery fire is the biggest danger they face. “You can hide from a sniper, but not from artillery, and they’re using large caliber.”

“Vydra,” a unit commander of the Pyatnashka fighters. [Source: Photo courtesy of Eva Bartlett]

His living quarters is a dank, cramped, room with a tiny improvised bed, with another small room and bed for others at the outpost.

A sign reads: “If shelling occurs, go to the shelter.” The kind of sign you see all over Donetsk and cities of the Donbas, due to Ukraine’s incessant shelling of civilian, residential areas. In a frontline outpost where incoming artillery is the norm, the sign is slightly absurd, clearly a joke.

An Orthodox icon sits atop the sign. Ukrainian nationalists hang and spray Nazi graffiti and slogans of death; these fighters revere their faith.

A poster, with the DPR flag, reads: “We have never known defeat, and it’s clear that this has been decided from above. Donbas has never been forced to its knees, and no one will ever be allowed to.

The only things decorating the space are tins of tuna and canned meat, instant noodles, and washing powder. Their existence is bare minimum, nothing glamorous about it; they volunteer because, as they told me, this is their land and they will protect it.

Perhaps surprising to some, when Vydra was asked whether he hates Ukrainians, he replied emphatically no, he has friends and relatives in Ukraine.

“We have no hatred for Ukraine. We hate those nationalists who came to power. But ordinary Ukrainians? Why? Many of us speak Ukrainian. We understand them, they understand us. Many of them speak Russian.

I’ve been involved in sports a lot of time, wrestling. So, I’ve got a lot of friends in Dnepropetrovsk, Kharkov, Kirovograd, Odessa, Lvov, Ivano-Frankivsk, Transcarpathia.

I have relatives in western Ukraine, and we still communicate. Yes, they say one thing on the street, but when we talk to each other, they say, ‘Well, you have to, because the SBU is listening.’

Ukraine shouts about democracy, then puts people in handcuffs for no reason. My aunt got in trouble because they found my photo on her Skype.

And I’m on the Myrotvorets [kill list] website.” [As is the author, see this article.]

He spoke of Ukraine’s shelling from 2014, when the people of the Donbass were unarmed and not expecting to be bombed by their own country.

“When the artillery hit the city of Yenakievo, east of Gorlovka, we were defenseless. We went with hunting rifles and torches to fight them. Most of the weapons we had later were captured from them. We had to go to the battlefield without weapons in order to get the weapons.”

When asked if he was concerned that Ukrainian forces might take Donetsk he replied no, of course not, they didn’t succeed in 2014, they won’t now.

When asked whether he had a message for soldiers of the Ukrainian army, Vydra replied without hesitating, “Go home! We’ve been saying that since 2014: Go home. Unequivocally, we don’t want them here, but we don’t want to kill them. I’m not speaking about nationalists, I’m speaking about Ukrainian soldiers, who are drafted or forcefully employed in the Ukrainian army. Guys, go home, either surrender or go. This is our land. We’re not leaving, we’re not going anywhere.”

I asked how he felt to be treated and described as sub-human, to be called dehumanizing names, a part of the Ukrainian nationalists’ brainwashing propaganda. As I wrote previously:

“Ukrainian nationalists openly declare they view Russians as sub-human. School books teach this warped ideology. Videos show the extent of this mentality: Teaching children not only to also hate Russians and see them as not humans, but also brainwashing them to believe killing Donbas residents is acceptable. The Ukrainian government itself funds neo-Nazi-run indoctrination camps for youths.”

“It’s offensive,” Vydra said, “We are saddened: There are sick people. We need to heal them, slowly.”

I asked whether he thought friendship between Ukrainians and Russians would be possible.

“It will take years for any friendship. Take Chechnya, one region of Russia, it was at war. But slowly, slowly…We must all live together. We are one people.” Indeed, now Chechen fighters are one of the most effective forces fighting alongside Donbas and Russian soldiers to liberate Donbas areas from Ukrainian forces.

He opened a zippered trousers pocket and proudly brandished a small plastic sleeve containing children’s drawings, also containing icons of saints and Christ, and prayers…

“This is very personal, it’s like my guardian angel. I put it in plastic, I don’t even keep my ID in plastic. I’ve been carrying this one in my pocket since February. I’ve been in all sorts of hot spots. A child drew this, we receive letters from children. It’s very nice to look at them when it’s hard and we are under fire.”

He read one letter:

We are waiting for you. Thank you for risking your lives to defend Donbas. Yulia and Ira.

“I don’t even know who are Yulia and Ira,” he said smiling.

Showing the icons, he said, “This is Saint Ushakov, our great commander. This is Jesus Christ, our Heavenly Protector. This Abkhazi icon was given to me by the guys. This is a prayer book. And here is a prayer,” he said of one page prayer.

“These words are to support when times are very hard. When there is heavy shelling, it can go on for hours. So, while you’re sitting there, you can read this.

Especially for the younger guys, 22, 23 years old, just finished college. This is new to them.”

Commanders Speak of Geopolitical Reasons for Ukraine’s War

Outside, sitting in front of an Orthodox banner and a collection of collected munitions—including Western ones—two platoon commanders, “Kabar” and “Kamaz,” spoke of the bigger geopolitical picture. [See video]

“America is running the show here,” Kabar said. “It builds foreign policy on the basis of how its domestic policy is built, which is through conflicts with external countries. They are accustomed to proving their power to their people through terrorism around the world, inciting fires in Syria, in the east. They played the card of radical Islam there.

And now they are playing the card of fascism. They do not see themselves on the other side of good. They need wars, blood, cruelty, and they signed Europe up for this.

However, they’ve missed one point: Russia, since the days of the Soviet Union, has never retreated in large scale wars. They took Europe and pushed it to slaughter Russia, and they put Russia in such a position that it must secure its national interests. Europe needs to understand this, to pay attention to history, to stop being led by the United States.”

“Kabar,” a commander of the Pyatnashka fighters. [Source: Photo courtesy of Eva Bartlett]

When asked about his feeling regarding Ukrainians, “Kabar” replied similarly to Vydra.

“We don’t blame the whole Ukrainian people. Ukrainians are our friends, they are our relatives. They’ve been struck by evil, and it’s not their fault, ordinary people are not to blame for this. We will liberate them from fascism, we’ll show them brotherhood, and we’ll make friends.

This is a good opportunity for us to defeat evil. God has honored us with this right to fight evil.”

Kamaz, when asked why he is fighting, replied that this is his homeland, he was born here, and that he has a son who he doesn’t want to inherit Ukraine’s war on the Donbas.

“I myself am Greek by nationality. Ukrainians are Slavs, they are our brothers, their grandfathers fought together shoulder to shoulder with our grandfathers against Nazism and fascism. We are here to finish it, so that our children live a normal happy life. We are fighting for the future.”

He spoke of America’s continuous need for war.

“We’ve seen it in Syria and Yugoslavia, where they destroyed everything and then set everything up their own way, so the people must submit, almost like slaves.”

I asked whether he thought peace between Ukraine and Russia is possible.

“Yes, possibly, why not? But at the moment, the President of Ukraine said there will be no negotiations.

Negotiations are possible, but I think not with this president. When he comes to his senses, he will not be able to negotiate, because he took a lot of money.”

Before leaving the outpost, we chatted a bit with the commanders. A puppy sought the attention of a young soldier. Another puppy ran around our feet. The outpost commanders and soldiers take care of the dogs. Their presence added a somewhat surreal touch to the scene: an outpost which is routinely shelled, where life can cease to exist at any moment, and these happy, well-cared for puppies running around like dogs anywhere.

Western Media Inverted Reality, Lauding Nazis and Demonizing Defenders

While many in the West think that this conflict started in February 2022, those following events since 2014 are aware that, following the Maidan coup and Odessa massacre, and the rise of fascism in Ukraine against the Ukrainian people, the Donbas republics wanted to distance themselves from Ukraine’s Nazis and fascism.

The sacrifices which the people of the Donbas republics have endured, particularly those fighting to protect their families and loved ones, have been and continue to be immense.

Just as the heroes of the Syrian Arab Army were maligned, so too have Donbas forces have been maligned by Western media, though both are defending their homelands from terrorist forces trained and funded by the West. Terrorists given the freedom to commit endless atrocities against Donbas civilians.

These defenders, many living in dank trench conditions didn’t choose war, they responded to it, to protect their loved ones and their future. In spite of more than eight years of being warred upon by Ukraine, they retain their humanity.


CovertAction Magazine is made possible by subscriptionsorders and donations from readers like you.

Blow the Whistle on U.S. Imperialism

 

 

Click the whistle and donate

 

When you donate to CovertAction Magazine, you are supporting investigative journalism. Your contributions go directly to supporting the development, production, editing, and dissemination of the Magazine.

CovertAction Magazine does not receive corporate or government sponsorship. Yet, we hold a steadfast commitment to providing compensation for writers, editorial and technical support. Your support helps facilitate this compensation as well as increase the caliber of this work.

Please make a donation by clicking on the donate logo above and enter the amount and your credit or debit card information.

CovertAction Institute, Inc. (CAI) is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization and your gift is tax-deductible for federal income purposes. CAI’s tax-exempt ID number is 87-2461683.

We sincerely thank you for your support.


Disclaimer: The contents of this article are the sole responsibility of the author(s). CovertAction Institute, Inc. (CAI), including its Board of Directors (BD), Editorial Board (EB), Advisory Board (AB), staff, volunteers and its projects (including CovertAction Magazine) are not responsible for any inaccurate or incorrect statement in this article. This article also does not necessarily represent the views the BD, the EB, the AB, staff, volunteers, or any members of its projects.

Differing viewpoints: CAM publishes articles with differing viewpoints in an effort to nurture vibrant debate and thoughtful critical analysis. Feel free to comment on the articles in the comment section and/or send your letters to the Editors, which we will publish in the Letters column.

Copyrighted Material: This web site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. As a not-for-profit charitable organization incorporated in the State of New York, we are making such material available in an effort to advance the understanding of humanity’s problems and hopefully to help find solutions for those problems. We believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. You can read more about ‘fair use’ and US Copyright Law at the Legal Information Institute of Cornell Law School.

Republishing: CovertAction Magazine (CAM) grants permission to cross-post CAM articles on not-for-profit community internet sites as long as the source is acknowledged together with a hyperlink to the original CovertAction Magazine article. Also, kindly let us know at info@CovertActionMagazine.com. For publication of CAM articles in print or other forms including commercial internet sites, contact: info@CovertActionMagazine.com.

By using this site, you agree to these terms above.


About the Author

20 COMMENTS

  1. Eva Bartlett’s coverage of the Ukraine war is among the very best. Better than Moon of Alabama, better than Alex and Alexander of Duran, better than Chris Hedges, better than ‘CIA’ Larry Johnson, et al. Unlike any of those armchair politicos, she is there on the frontlines risking her own life to bring us the truth of what is going on. Thank you Eva for your courageous, excellent journalism. Kudos and please stay safe!

  2. Another excellent article, Eva. Thank you so much for showing us the human side of war and the commendable humanity of the Donbas Defenders.

  3. Thank you Eva Bartlett for another well researched introspection into the human reality of western foreign foreign funding of violent foreign imposed destabilization. I’m Canadian & shocked at colonial Canada’s ongoing major support of violent destabilization interventions in 2nd world countries like Ukraine & 3rd world countries everywhere. Unfortunately Canada is the number one nation of foreign extraction & exploitation per capita through our world dominant mining & forestry corporations. We rape & pillage more per capita than the USA & others. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/relational-economy/7-Canada-1-war-monger
    The difference between Eva & most writers, bloggers & the few monologue trolls here, is that she stands behind what she publishes, I proffer that; Eva, given support of her expenses, will gladly meet with & formally ‘debate’ (French ‘de’ = ‘undo’ + ‘bate’ = ‘the-fight’) in both-sided, equal-time, recorded & published dialogue with anyone representing organizations who disagree with part or the whole of her experience, research or assertions. As will I, albeit with less specific knowledge. Eva’s research always connects with real-people, typically the most impoverished & oppressed, on the ground as evidenced by her presence.in Donbass. Unlike most reporters, who only write ‘monologues’, Eva writes in living ‘dialogues’ with real people & is willing to engage her critics publicly in full dialogue. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/structure/both-sides-now-equal-time-recorded-dialogues

    • Douglas Jack is obviously sincere and well meaning as his depiction of Canada’s role in committing crimes above its weight class in the service of the US makes clear. But he doesn’t have a clue what separates a genuine journalist from a fan of this or that cause who happens to write about it. Whatever else, positive or negative, Eva Bartlett might be, she is NOT a journalist, To make this clear I just took another look at her article and found this paragraph:

      “Just as the heroes of the Syrian Arab Army were maligned, so too have Donbas forces have been maligned by Western media, though both are defending their homelands from terrorist forces trained and funded by the West. Terrorists given the freedom to commit endless atrocities against Donbas civilians.”

      No journalist, self-respecting or otherwise would ever write such twaddle. Robert Fisk, who was a long time friend, covered the Middle East and Syria for decades, would look at that sentence and denounce it as “rubbish.”

      Bartlett was apparently given the blessings of Bashar al-Assad, who immediately after 9/11 volunteered Syria to be part of the CIA’s rendition program (and the record shows that it carried out its duties on the CIA’s behalf) to embed herself with the Russian army as it invaded Ukraine. Embedding oneself in an invading army is something else a genuine journalist would think twice about doing but since Putin did Assad a favor by having his air force bomb Aleppo into rubble, I suspect she didn’t even consider refusing the opportunity to be where the action was.

      • There are many aspects of being a good journalist. One aspect is to try to look at both sides of a story or conflict. If journalists are employed by the Syria Government, the Russian Government or the American Government, often these journalists will favor one side over the other rather than provide unbiased neutral reporting.

        • Although it is more than likely she is being paid by the Syrian government, and maybe now by Russia, as well–reporters have to live, after all–I would believe that she was more attracted to both entities because, as she perceives them, they align with her political perspective.

          It is clear that for someone who lived in Gaza for four years, as we are told she did, and who has obvious sympathies with the Palestinians, as I have had for the last half century, she is either unaware or has reconciled herself to the fact that Putin and Netanyahu have the closest of relationships which has been kept secret by Washington and the US media for obvious reasons (see Dave Chappelle) to the point where Putin hosted Netanyahu on at least seven official state visits and Netanyahu’s campaign posters carried portraits of both men, obviously designed to appeal to the more than a million Russian-born Israelis who still receive Russian government pensions and and are able to vote in Russian elections.

        • I agree with this remark from Colin. Leftists should not embrace despotic regimes abroad simply because they oppose U.S. Imperialism. Lenin called that “Revolutionary Infantilism.”

  4. This Vice video seems as much a product of US-NATO propaganda as does the article by Eva Bartlett, one of Bashar Assad’s favorite foreign mouthpieces, who, apparently on loan from Damascus, was embedded with the Russian army from the very beginning of its February invasion.

    Yes, there was a US-backed coup back in 2014, but, I would argue, that the coup only occurred after months of protests by ordinary Ukrainians in response to Yanukovch having agreed, following a meeting with a group of European leaders, to hold a new presidential election two months later, after which he would step down and turn the government over peacefully, without bloodshed,

    Had that occurred, it is unlikely that Putin would have found it necessary to annex Crimea (which, unlike the Donbass) which was an autonomous region of Ukraine with its only legislative set-up and which had a right to secede. A peaceful transfer of power was the last thing the US would allow, however, because forcing Putin to annex Crimea, home to Russia’s only Black Sea port, was obviously believed necessary to justify the rejuvenation of NATO, the future need for which prior to the Maidan protests was being questioned in the Western media.

    That’s when the coup, carried out by Ukrainian neo-Nazis, was ordered apparently by Washington, but the crowds of Ukrainians who had camped out and protested the government of the manifestly corrupt president for months and who objected to him agreeing to a bailout from Russia as opposed to a “loan” from the INF weren’t there because the CIA or Victoria Nuland, with her cookies, put them up to it is absurd, as is the belief, all too common among the Western Left, that the CIA and a character named Gene Sharp put them up to it. That attitude mirrors the allegations that we once heard from Washington that everyone resisting US and Western imperialism, from Vietnam to Nicaragua, from Chile to South Africa, were puppets of the Soviet Union. Sadly, denying agency to peoples whose histories we don’t know and whose languages we don’t speak has been as much the position of the US left as it has those running the show from Washington.

    • Correction in the above ” that the CIA and a character named Gene Sharp put them up to it” should read ” that the CIA and a character named Gene Sharp were behind the so-called “color revolutions” of the past era.”

    • We know exactly what happened in Ukraine since before the Maidan, evidence is easily available all over the Internet. Spreading false information to excuse the atrocities of Azov is futile. Putin for many years never liked Nazi’s.

Leave a Reply