They See Only the Bad Old Days of the Soviet Union
The CIA, thanks to Hollywood and fanboys, enjoys an undeserved reputation for competence in carrying out espionage and covert actions.
I am fascinated by the delusional punditry offered by former CIA officers, such as Douglas London and Steven Hall. Full disclosure, Hall was a young 20 something in my Career Trainee class (we entered on duty in September 1985). He is emblematic, in my opinion, of the problems that have plagued the CIA over the last thirty years–he was a legacy, i.e. got into the agency in part because his Daddy preceded him.
Steve, if you recall, was one of the liars who signed a letter declaring that Hunter Biden’s laptop had all the earmarks of Russian disinformation. Attaching himself to such a libelous letter (he was impugning the character of John Paul Mac Isaac) highlights his tendency to follow the herd and eschew critical thinking.
But I want to focus on Douglas London. He is popping up all over media, especially CNN and the Wall Street Journal, and offering analysis that ranges from the banal to the delusional.
Consider this snippet, published in the Wall Street Journal, in March:
“I spent 34 years in the Central Intelligence Agency’s clandestine service, and watching Vladimir Putin’s brutal war in Ukraine from the sidelines fills me with both sadness and a sense of opportunity. Espionage is a predatory business, and there’s blood in the water. Mr. Putin’s self-inflicted damage has done more to turn his own people against him than anything the West could have done. . . .
Russian mystique is gone. Mr. Putin has proved his country is the declining power that the best-informed Russia watchers claimed it was. Fewer pundits will wax poetic over Mr. Putin’s cunning and strategic brilliance. He might have been a capable operations officer during his KGB career, but he clearly missed the classes on self-awareness and counterintelligence. The more he tightens the security screws and covers Russia’s window to the world, the more likely those he depends on will turn against him.”
Got that? Russia, whose economy is clicking along nicely in contrast to the implosion underway in Europe, is a declining power in Mr. London’s fanciful world. Since the start of the Special Military Operation last February, Putin has frustrated Western attempts to paint him as Hitler reincarnated and has forged closer ties with China, India, Saudi Arabia and Brazil. Oh, did I mention he enjoys popular support among the Russian people:
The proportion of Russian citizens’ confidence in President Vladimir Putin stood at over 80%, according to the All-Russian Public Opinion Research Center that published the results of a survey conducted from October 3 to 9 among 1,600 respondents aged over 18, reports TASS.
“When asked about trust in Putin, 80.9% of respondents answered positively (-0.2% over the week), the approval rate of the Russian president’s work was 75.6% (-1.3 % over the week),” the pollsters noted.
I want to remind you of the desperation of the West to portray Putin as a loser bereft of popular support. Five years ago, Statista claimed that Putin was losing popular support:
According to a Pew Research Center survey released last week, Russians still have a high level of confidence in President Putin’s ability to do the right thing regarding world affairs. Despite his high overall approval rating, however, Putin is actually losing public support on many key issues. Support for his handling of relations with Ukraine and the EU have dropped 20 and 15 percentage points respectively since 2015. Russians are also increasingly dissatisfied with the way their president is handing relations with the United States.
If you thought that an experienced spook like London would take the time to actually gather some facts and compare them to history, think again. Sure looks like Mr. London is not about to let facts get in his way. London believes that his ability to speak Russian grants him special insight into the mind of Vladimir Putin. Here is his keen analysis from a recent column in “Just Security“:
Policymakers would do well to remember three fundamentals that guide Putin’s decision-making: 1) he is the product of the 1970’s and 1980’s KGB and stood witness in then-East Germany in 1991, when the world as he knew it ceased to exist; 2) ego, survival, greed, and ambition direct his moral compass; and 3) he has come to believe his own propaganda.
Unlike all other political leaders, Putin is driven by “ego, survival, greed, and ambition.” Excuse me, but good grief!! Thank God that neither Bill Clinton nor Barack Obama nor Boris Johnson were motivated to run for office because of “ego, survival, greed, and ambition.” Any further question why I deride London as banal. Hell, Mr. London does not even understand himself, i.e., what motivates him. Apart from Jesus Christ, I have not had the privilege of knowing any political leader of substance that was free of ego, self-preservation, greed and ambition.
This kind of superficial, shallow thinking is part of the reason that officers like London wormed their way up the ranks of the CIA bureaucracy. As long as you mouth platitudes and do not rock the boat of established thinking, you get a great Personal Appraisal Report (aka PAR), and are promoted in accordance with the Peter Principle.
The London Express asked Mr. London about Putin’s decision to name General Sergey Surovikin as Supreme Commander of the Military Operation in Ukraine:
Douglas London, . . . believes Vladimir Putin did not appoint Surovikin on merit but because the Russian Air Force Commander lacks the connections within the military to launch a coup. Putin installed Surovikin, nicknamed “General Armageddon,” to oversee Russian operations in Ukraine this month after a run of heavy defeats at the hands of Ukrainian forces in Kherson and Kharkiv. . . .
General Surovikin previously headed up Russian operations during the Syrian Civil War when Moscow propped up the regime of Bashir Al-Assad against Islamist rebel forces.
He was credited with masterminding the recapture of large swathes of Syria from rebel hands, the use of overwhelming firepower, and scant regard for collateral damage.
Surovikin’s appointment as the top Russian commander in Ukraine coincided with the use of widespread suicide drones to target Ukrainian energy infrastructure.
Got that? Surovikin is without “merit”, yet he is credited with capturing large portions of Syria from Islamic rebels. If Douglas London really had any analytical talent at all–along with some intellectual honesty–he could have at least acknowledged that Putin’s choice of Surovikin was in fact grounded in merit.
Putin was not looking for some boot licking toady to kiss his ass and tell him what a wonderful dictator he is. Putin selected a General with experience in running a combined arms operation with a clear track record of success.
I don’t know if London is just stupid and ignorant or if he sincerely believes the nonsense he is spouting. Could it be that his own experience as a boot licker is clouding his judgment?
U.S. policymakers, when it comes to Russia, are an ignorant lot with little appreciation for history. They are blinded by ideology and tend to view present day Russia through the expired constructs of the Cold War. Putin and Russia are inept. They are bumbling. They are backward. Etc.,etc. etc.
None take into account the remarkable transformation of life in Russia under Putin during the last 22 years. Russia was a genuine shit hole in 1999. Rather than spend Russian tax dollars on disastrous foreign policy expeditions like Iraq and Afghanistan, under Putin’s leadership the creaky, rotten infrastructure left by the Soviet regime was renovated and modernized.
Russia’s military services also were upgraded dramatically and its technological skills, particularly in the realm of space exploration, surpassed that of the West. The vast majority of people in the United States fail to appreciate the implications of Russia’s role in providing the rockets and space craft that ferried U.S. astronauts to the Space Station.
Back in 2004, President Bush announced that NASA’s aging space shuttle program would be retired in 2010 and—eventually—replaced by a plan to return to the moon. At the time, NASA realized there would be a four-year gap between the space-shuttle retirement and when the new manned space transport system would be in place.
But at that point, it didn’t seem like a big problem for NASA to ask Russia to transport U.S. astronauts to and from the space station in the interim. Relations between the two countries were friendly—Bush was telling reporters that he’d looked into Putin’s eyes and “got a sense of his soul.” What’s more, NASA had relied on Russian transport for 29 months after the Columbia disaster in 2003, when the shuttle program was put on hold.
Development of NASA’s replacement vessels, however, has taken much longer than anticipated—the agency won’t have a replacement for the shuttle until 2017. There are a few reasons for that. Bush’s moon program was cancelled by Obama in 2010 and replaced with a plan for private companies to shuttle astronauts. Meanwhile, NASA’s budget requests to pay for the new program were repeatedly underfunded by Congress.
Just to be clear. The incompetent, inept, backward, technologically unsophisticated Russians have been the Uber driver for the United States, carrying U.S. astronauts to and from the International Space Station.
But when it comes to running military operations in Ukraine, the Russians supposedly cannot pour piss out of a boot. I offer this as the clearest example of the delusion that blinds the minds of supposed super spies like Douglas London and Steve Hall and others.
Instead of acknowledging that Russia, notwithstanding its relatively small population compared to other countries, is a certified leader in sophisticated, complex technology, Western intelligence officials and politicians only see the bad old days of the Soviet Union and the craven party politics that sundered the Soviet empire.
The West fails to understand that there is a new kid on the block who is not going to buckle or cower in the face of belligerent threats from the cretins in the West. A failure to know one’s opponent (or enemy) is a recipe for disaster. Sadly, I fear the West is consumed by that recipe and will continue to fight a figment of their collective imagination that no longer exists.
CovertAction Magazine is made possible by subscriptions, orders and donations from readers like you.
Blow the Whistle on U.S. Imperialism
Click the whistle and donate
When you donate to CovertAction Magazine, you are supporting investigative journalism. Your contributions go directly to supporting the development, production, editing, and dissemination of the Magazine.
CovertAction Magazine does not receive corporate or government sponsorship. Yet, we hold a steadfast commitment to providing compensation for writers, editorial and technical support. Your support helps facilitate this compensation as well as increase the caliber of this work.
Please make a donation by clicking on the donate logo above and enter the amount and your credit or debit card information.
CovertAction Institute, Inc. (CAI) is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization and your gift is tax-deductible for federal income purposes. CAI’s tax-exempt ID number is 87-2461683.
We sincerely thank you for your support.
Disclaimer: The contents of this article are the sole responsibility of the author(s). CovertAction Institute, Inc. (CAI), including its Board of Directors (BD), Editorial Board (EB), Advisory Board (AB), staff, volunteers and its projects (including CovertAction Magazine) are not responsible for any inaccurate or incorrect statement in this article. This article also does not necessarily represent the views the BD, the EB, the AB, staff, volunteers, or any members of its projects.
Differing viewpoints: CAM publishes articles with differing viewpoints in an effort to nurture vibrant debate and thoughtful critical analysis. Feel free to comment on the articles in the comment section and/or send your letters to the Editors, which we will publish in the Letters column.
Copyrighted Material: This web site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. As a not-for-profit charitable organization incorporated in the State of New York, we are making such material available in an effort to advance the understanding of humanity’s problems and hopefully to help find solutions for those problems. We believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. You can read more about ‘fair use’ and US Copyright Law at the Legal Information Institute of Cornell Law School.
Republishing: CovertAction Magazine (CAM) grants permission to cross-post CAM articles on not-for-profit community internet sites as long as the source is acknowledged together with a hyperlink to the original CovertAction Magazine article. Also, kindly let us know at info@CovertActionMagazine.com. For publication of CAM articles in print or other forms including commercial internet sites, contact: info@CovertActionMagazine.com.
By using this site, you agree to these terms above.
About the Author
Larry C. Johnson is a veteran of the CIA and the State Department’s Office of Counter Terrorism.
He is the founder and managing partner of BERG Associates, which was established in 1998. Larry provided training to the U.S. Military’s Special Operations community for 24 years. He has been vilified by both the Right and Left.
Larry can be reached at email@example.com.
[…] Av Larry C. Johnson , 26 november. Källa: https://covertactionmagazine.com/2022/11/26/star-cia-analysts-are-out-of-touch-with-reality-when-it-… […]
[…] Star CIA Analysts Are Out of Touch With Reality When it Comes to Russia […]
[…] https://covertactionmagazine.com/2022/11/26/star-cia-analysts-are-out-of-touch-with-reality-when-it-… […]
Covert Action Magazine used to have highly qualified writers like Pat Elder who wrote about toxins and environment problems. But lately all the writers are much less qualified than Pat Elder. It would be nice to see more qualified writers like Pat Elder and others like Andrew Lee who was excellent.
Out of touch with reality? I don’t think so. Try, committed to a disinformation narrative.
When a whole intelligence service and the bulk of its alumni start spreading an obviously false narrative in public, and the major news media in their native country parrot that narrative without a hint of fact checking or critical analysis, we are seeing a Big Lie campaign.
Anybody with any knowledge knows that CIA agents never really leave the agency, never expose the evils within it, and are snakes. There is a major conspiracy going on. The war in UKraine, like most contrived events (I am not saying it is not happening, I am saying it was created as is intentionally by the real rulers) is for the benefit of the powers’ depopulation agenda. We are clearly headed towards world war, and the US has manipulated their position to “force” Russia into it. I do not watch the idiots’ propaganda machine tv, but research independently. With this article, the magazine has lost my support and faith (called faith due to it not being fact, but only “belief” in its accuracy) in its newsworthiness. I am cancelling my subscription. THanks for inviting me to a dinner I could not afford. I don’t report propaganda for money as it appears you do, so I cannot afford the bus and train to see you, and now have no remorse missing it.
Larry C. Johnson’s piece is excellent, but to me, there is one particular missing detail: the fact that Russia and America are in the permanent UN Security Council, to discuss together, like very good friends, what to do to the world. Their discussions and negotiations are strengthened via traditional diplomacy, USA’s Embassy in Moscow and Russia’s Embassy in Washington. To further bolster USA-Russia business partnerships, America pays for three Consulates in Russia and Russia pays for four Consulates in America.
The rest is all an expensive Theater, a costly comedy and tragedy to help promote tensions, fear of war and war Politics is the dirtiest and more corrupt business in the world, due to the ignorant, gullible and passive masses, brainwashed until they become patriots and believe War Forces are necessary for their security. Nothing more absurd and wrong.
Espionage led to to World Wars one and two and it is helping now politicians create World War III.
SAD, VERY SAD.
First of all, information from the intelligence agencies should NEVER leak to media. That is not serious. I guess that most of the time, these leaks are deliberate disinformation
Nicolas, both corporate journalists and secret agents are paid to lie. In a world run by the economy of War, there is no option. People all over the want to live in Peace, nobody wants to ne without education, without medical care, without food, without a home. However, the War industry requires an unhappy society, brainwashed to believe war is the solution to their problems. Lies are the No.1 ingredient for creating military business.
I have worked 30 years for the French State, a long time as intelligence officer. My job was not lie but prevention of terrorist attacks. We were pretty successful, then. If the West is now a bunch of post-truth societies, the issue is not intelligence agencies but new generations, arrogance, cowardice and servility
It sounds like the Lies worked so well…that you think you’re telling the truth … Where does “Terrorism” come from? OPERATION GLADIO – that’s where …
And thereafter, the ‘plausibly deniable’ secret army of the West, Takfiri Wahabi Jihadists – whether they call themselves “Al Qaeda” – “The (Oliver North Data-)Base”, “ISIS” or “Boko Haram” – they’re simply shock troops, used to overturn uncooperative foreign Governments. But sometimes, they get targeted domestically, whether by foot soldiers who don’t realize who they’re actually working for… Or, occasionally, on orders come from echelons higher than your own, within the Western Intelligence complex – when a “self-inflicted wound” serves some larger strategic objective – like the removal of civil liberties, and suppression of internal dissent.
To argue that the Intelligence Community model is based upon telling the truth – demonstrates a remarkable naiveté. Perhaps inside the building, in a Sensitive Compartmented Intelligence, ‘eyes only’, NOFORN report…but the stuff for external distribution is invariably propaganda and PSYOPS.
Please, be less arrogant, funny westerner 🦄
Calm down and wear you tin foiled hat
Please be less arrogant, funny Westerner 🦄
Calm down and wear your tin foil hat.
I know very well how bigmouths like you cry like babies, when competent operatives, not aliens, manage to carry out a well organized terrorist operation 😊
Where does Covert Action Magazine lie on the Left Right scale? Lately CAM seems to be hiring a lot of Far Right journalists.
Alex Jones would probably love this article
I assume that you are alluding that the article is conspiracy? Do you have any evidence or argumentation to refute the article’s analysis?
[…] Star CIA Analysts Are Out of Touch With Reality When it Comes to Russia, by Larry C. Johnson […]
Larry Johnson is a first rate source. I use his insights regularly in my articles on Russia, the Ukraine and the global conflict. Visit his site and support him.
Yes, whatever the CIA wants to think, Russia is winning.
Thanks Larry. I am an older person and remember even in the bad old days when I visited the USSR in 1966. This was not a country of fear and hatred, but the USA members of the group I travelled with were not allowed to admit back home that they had dared to enter the evil empire. Not a mark on their passports! As an Australian, this was not demanded of us!!
The McCarthy fear and loathing seems to have remained. I now live in France, and the books now available on the CIA influence here show the shocking amount of hubris as the USA decides what suits any other “sovereign nation” it pretends to be allied to.
How any genuine observer or thinker could possibly believe any of the comments London makes defies belief. Twenty years of Putin’s speeches, any list of the countries and leaders with whom he has good relations, even checking out his statements for truth, would allow any decent person to make a fairer judgment.
“They See Only the Bad Old Days of the Soviet Union” It sounds like your source of your information about “the bad old days of the Soviet Union” comes from the same bunch of CIA analysts that are “getting it wrong” now. The Soviet Union had its problems but not what the CIA says. The CIA are elites who lie about and fight against any working people who fight against their chains. The greatest fear of the “masters” is a slave uprising.
CIA scum analysts are generally out of touch with reality about almost everything!
Sounds like these guys are typical NeoCons, stewing in the centuries old Russophobic stew of the Marquis de Custine, and the added imperial spices of Zbigniew Brzezinski. At the same time that Russia is an incompetent and backwards power, in the afterglow of its salad days… It’s ALSO, somehow, a gigantic menace, a threat to European Security, and a dangerous imperialist power.
Someone should ask these two idiots to do a write-up on the real threat to world peace, and the really incompetent Global Empire… How popular do they think Joe Biden is? About the same as Donald Trump was, if we’re to believe the polling…but I don’t.
The MOCKINGBIRD Pressitutes, and DNCIA PR firms do anything they can to paint Joe Biden in a better light – jist like they did anything that they could to undermine and contain Trump (to one term, and from initiating any rapprochement with Russia, or North Korea).
The takes on Russia, described in this article, sound like a combination of the “A-Team” from the CIA of the 1970’s (under Carter), and the B-Team (Committee on the Present Danger) spooks brought in under Reagan.