A group of people wearing masks

Description automatically generated with medium confidence
AFL-CIO President Liz Shuler, left, with Israeli Labor Party leader Merav Michaeli, center, and Randi Weingarten, head of the American Federation of Teachers (AFT), right. [Source: indaybay.org]

Shameful behavior fits long history of AFL-CIO support for the Histadrut, an arm of the Israeli state.

Much of the world was horrified in early May when Shireen Abu Akleh, a renowned Al Jazeera reporter, was shot in the head by Israeli troops while on assignment in Jenin in the Occupied West Bank.

Not long before, the American Federation of Labor-Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO) President Liz Shuler had been photographed with Labor Party Chair Merav Michaeli, a strong supporter of the Israeli occupation of the West Bank, along with Randi Weingarten, the president of the American Federation of Teachers (AFT). None of the three raised any outcry subsequently after Akleh was killed.

Shuler moreover sent a letter to the San Francisco Labor Council stating that its delegates could not discuss a boycott of Israel.

The AFL-CIO’s current support for Israel fits a long historical pattern. For decades now, it has allied with and sheltered the Histadrut, the Israeli trade union federation, and the Israeli state from any criticisms.

Handmaiden of the Israeli State

The Histadrut is the handmaiden of the Israeli state, and the Israeli state is a junior partner to American imperialism. The Histadrut has billed itself as a labor union and thus the defender of the Israeli working class but, if one examines it honestly, without the Histadrut, Israeli capitalism would have had a hard time getting off the ground.

The early founders of the Israeli state concur that without the Histadrut, there would likely have been no Israeli state. It does not have any semblance of independence because it is part of the state apparatus. While the Histadrut is in no way a labor union, the AFL-CIO pretends that it is.

In the March 2009 Electronic Intifada article “Histadrut: Israel’s racist ‘trade union,” Tony Greenstein pointed out that Golda Meir explained in 1928, “I was put on the Histadrut Executive Committee at a time when this big labor union wasn’t just a trade union organization. It was a great colonizing agency.” Israel’s first Prime Minister, David Ben-Gurion, contended that, without Histadrut, “I doubt whether we would have had a state.”

Golda Meir and David Ben-Gurion, Jerusalem, 1962 | Jewish Women's Archive
David Ben-Gurion and Golda Meir at the Knesset in Jerusalem in 1962. [Source: jwa.org]

Trade unions often function as a bridge between the needs of the bosses and those of the workers, but with a trade union such as the Histadrut, with its lack of any semblance of independence, it is virtually impossible to call this a trade union.

The fascists of both the Mussolini and Hitler stripes led states that were corporatist states, that is everyone who participated in the economy was “represented” by the state as opposed to having independent organizations that could pressure the government to bend to their needs.

The unions were not independent, they sat on the corporate boards. In the case of Italy, the unions were completely smashed and what remained was a representative, but in the case of Israel, the Histadrut is part of the capitalist class itself.

It helped to organize capitalism and helped to drive out the indigenous peoples, that is, they helped to colonize Palestine.

In a series of strikes that were either mixed, that is Palestinian and Jew, or were organized by Palestinian workers alone, the Histadrut sent in strikebreakers.

Therefore, if we examine the remarks of the two most influential persons in the Israeli project, that is Golda Meir and David Ben-Gurion, it is clear in an unabashed explanation that the Histadrut is an arm of the Israeli state, not only an organizer of industry, and is part of the settler colonial project and, unlike the sellout politics and class collaborationist politics of the AFL-CIO, the very purpose of the Histadrut was to get this project under way.

Histadrut was the owner of 25% of the capitalist industries which often employed strikebreakers so that any independent activity of the working class would be shut down. Thus, any well-respected capitalist nation wishes and needs to expand its economic and political influence in the rest of the world, but for the moment, the Israelis decided that the Middle East was its back door.

Imperialism thus became the driving force of the Israeli economy.

Tony Greenstein also argues that, “in 1958, the International Institute for Development, Cooperation and Labor Studies was established as a means of furthering Western interests in the Third World. Half of its graduates came from The Asian Institute for Labor Studies and Cooperation funded by the CIA through the AFL-CIO. It operated on behalf of the U.S. in African countries such as Zaire and Kenya.” It thus operated as an arm of Israeli and U.S. foreign policy.

Israel and Apartheid South Africa

Israel has often been described as an apartheid state because of its mistreatment of the Palestinians. It is not that well known, however, that Israel was actively committed to supporting the apartheid regime in South Africa.

Not seeing this as a morally repugnant nation, Israel armed the white South African regime, modeling its own policies on South African apartheid, suppressing the Palestinian people.

A group of men talking

Description automatically generated with medium confidence
Menachem Begin, Moshe Dayan and Yitzhak Rabin visiting with South African Prime Minister B.J. Vorster (third from the left) in Jerusalem in 1976. [Source: africaisacountry.com]

Tony Greenstein wrote: “Iskoor steel company, 51 percent owned by Histadrut’s Koor Industries and 49 percent by the South African Steel Corporation, manufactured steel for South Africa’s armed forces. Partly finished steel was shipped from Israel to South Africa, enabling the apartheid state to escape tariffs.”

Greenstein continued: “Other Histadrut companies such as Tadiran and Soltam were equally complicit in supplying South Africa with weaponry. [It] also helped build the electronic wall between South Africa/Namibia and neighboring African states.”

In the early 1960s, the Histadrut was a conduit for CIA and Mossad in Africa and later cooperated with the AFL-CIO’s AIFLD program and the CIA to undermine rural cooperatives in El Salvador.

Mossad agent David Ben Uziel photographed while training South Sudanese rebels in 1969-71 (photo credit: FROM ‘ON A MOSSAD MISSION TO SOUTH SUDAN)
Mossad agent David Ben Uziel photographed training South Sudanese rebels in 1969-1971. [Source: jpost.com]

Suppressing Class Struggle and Discriminating Against Arabs

Histadrut is recognized by the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions as the representative of all Israeli workers, even though its very nature is to discriminate against Arab workers. However, class struggle was anathema to the Histadrut generally.

In 1951, seamen who were on strike were drafted into the army with Histadrut support. This goes back as far as the 1920s when the Gdud Avodah workers went on strike and were starved into submission by Ben-Gurion.

The organization’s class collaborationism has not only undermined Arab workers, but it has undermined Jewish workers as well, with the inevitable outcome that we are witnessing now, that is with the utter racism that is being displayed by many of the Jewish working class.

This is how a capitalist arrives at implanting a colonial settler state. The Jewish working class, at the beginning of this project, believed that it was setting up a socialist society; the Jewish capitalists thought differently and used this desire for liberation as a battering ram against Palestinians who are the indigenous peoples.

All the evidence points to the criminality of people such as Ben-Gurion who explicitly said that class struggle meant struggle against Arab labor.

Ben-Gurion argued that “the role of the working class was a national one, to construct the Jewish state: “Socialism was never an aim in itself but a tool for the advancement of national objectives.” It was Ben-Gurion who “coined the slogan from class to nation…both perspectives saw the role of labor as a nationalist role.”

This perspective was one that was very much supported by fascist governments such as Mussolini’s Italy.

The Histadrut founded Haganah, the Zionist terrorist group, in the 1920s and Mapai, which became the Israeli Labor Party, in the 1930s. Greenstein wrote that Ben-Gurion was “Histadrut’s first secretary-general, became in 1935 chairman of the Jewish Agency, the Zionist government-in-waiting, and in 1948 prime minister of the State of Israel.”

Israeli Government Press Office photo
David Ben-Gurion addresses Histadrut members at the cornerstone-laying ceremony for the Histadrut building in Jerusalem in September 1924.
David Ben-Gurion addresses Histadrut members in 1924. [Source: atlantajewishtimes.com]

Ben-Gurion made it clear that there was no reason to respect Palestinian rights and that it was also clear that the Palestinians, understandably, would not give up their land without a fight.

He stated that “we do not recognize the right of the [Palestinian] Arabs to rule the country, since Palestine is still undeveloped and awaits its builders.”

And so the Labor Party was created and, it too pretends that it is somehow championing the cause of labor.

The list of Israeli crimes has been documented in thousands of books, but it is the pretend nature of its support for workers, that is, it is a labor union of some sort, which allows the AFL-CIO to pretend as well.

The list of crimes of the Israeli state and its partner the Histadrut is much more extensive, but having limited space, the focus of this article is on the relationship between the AFL-CIO and the Histadrut and the Israeli state.

On the Side of the Oppressor

So why is the AFL coming down on the side of the oppressor?

The history of the AFL has been one of racism and sexism and elitism from the very jump. It historically worked and continues to work with management, protecting white male workers, and thus they have been able to win contracts more effectively for the aristocracy of labor, but in the process, it has sold out everyone else. Therefore, they are no stranger to organizations such as the Histadrut and will thus lend a hand to the bosses.

The willingness of the largest trade union federation in the U.S. to cover up the crimes of the histadrut and the Israeli government by not supporting BDS, allows the Israeli government to act with impunity, thus the killing of Shereen. Shuler has said nothing about the murder, continuing the AFL-CIO’s support of the Israeli state and the oppression of the Palestinian people.

National AFL-CIO Western Region Field Director Fernando Losada said: “Expressions of solidarity [are] always good, But in terms of setting international policy, that is the purview of the national AFL-CIO through our organizational processes. There’s an existing policy in solidarity with working people in the Holy Land. It does not include BDS.”

According to The Intercept, AFL-CIO leadership cited a procedural rule to tell the San Francisco Labor Council it could not even debate a resolution on BDS.

[Source: theintercept.com]

I am of the opinion, and it is the opinion of others in the Labor Education Project on AFL-CIO International Operations (LEPAIO), that the AFL-CIO is complicit in the murder of Shireen and so many others since Shuler and Weingarten met with the leader of the Israeli Labor Party and Shuler sent a letter to the San Francisco Labor Council stating that delegates could not discuss a boycott of Israel.

Shireen Abu Akleh
Shireen Abu Akleh [Source: aljazeera.com]

Let us not forget that the Interior Minister of Israel is a member of the Labor Party who supported the murder of the journalist, and the Labor Party supports the apartheid state and Liz Shuler supports the State of Israel.

Thus, instead of being in solidarity with the Palestinians, U.S. labor has taken the side of the oppressor.

Every time members of any union have attempted to defend the rights of the Palestinians, the AFL-CIO has stepped in to defend the Israeli state and has either sidelined Palestinian rights or has forcefully defended the actions of the Israelis and have prevented any dissent among its members.

This is clearly demonstrated in a manual written by the Jewish Labor Committee in 2008 for pro-Israel lobby groups. It blatantly advises:

“Please DO NOT discuss with union members, representatives of the press or others, guesstimates of the value of State of Israel Bonds held by unions. ‘Divest from Israel’ activists have used such information in their arguments and have quoted figures found in Jewish newspapers and/or provided by Jewish communal representatives.”

Randi Weingarten, the President of the AFT, is a member of this organization.

Since the 1950s, the U.S. labor movement has continued to invest in Israeli bonds using their pension funds. The American labor unions collectively hold millions in Israeli bonds. The AFT alone reported to the DOL that the union has invested $200,000 in State of Israel bonds. Richard Trumka, the former head of the AFL-CIO, absolutely opposed support for BDS.

Richard L. Trumka
Richard L. Trumka [Source: obamawhitehouse.archives.org]

Change Gonna Come?

But now, things are decidedly changing, that is, there is more of an awareness among American workers that the situation in Israel is untenable and they will no longer support the repression of the Palestinians.

More recently (2010), members of the Connecticut AFL-CIO successfully got the state labor federation to dump its $25,000 in Israeli bonds and, five years later, the Connecticut federation passed a resolution calling on the national AFL-CIO to support BDS. (This vote was later annulled by Trumka.)

Pickets Challenge Labor to Find Solidarity with Palestinians | Labor Notes
Fifty activists picketed an awards dinner in June 2011, telling then-New York State AFL-CIO President Denis Hughes that his support for investments in Israel betrays basic principles of labor solidarity. [Source: labornotes.org]

But just recently, major unions and labor federations in Oregon passed unprecedented resolutions calling for divestment from an Israeli company over its human rights abuses.

In Oregon, the AFL-CIO and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), collectively representing more than 300,000 workers in the state, passed a resolution calling for the state to divest from the fund that owns Israeli spyware firm NSO.

Hindus for Human Rights on Twitter: "Oregon's state pension fund  @OregonTreasury invests in the NSO Group, whose spyware has been used by  authoritarian regimes in India, Israel, and around the world to
[Source: twitter.com]

And finally, in my union, the Professional Staff Congress, the International Committee, along with the Academic Freedom Committee and the Anti-Racism Committee, passed a resolution on Palestine (May 2021) which passed almost unanimously at the Delegate Assembly.

Almost immediately afterwards, the Zionists in the union went on the attack and the resolution has all but been suppressed. The Zionists, as we can see, hold tremendous sway in the unions.

American workers are far ahead of our “leaders” and, with a different leadership, we could make headway fighting for the democratic rights of oppressed peoples; but if we don’t break, not only on this issue, but similar ones such as a women’s right to choose, Black rights, etc., we will be moving closer and closer to a fascist society.

The economy is breaking down and right before our eyes, the society is disintegrating. Workers need a new leadership. Victory can only be won with a conscious, organized working class that is willing to build a movement that will knock down the barriers that capitalism sets up to divide us and that means we must start by dumping our “leaders” and replacing them with a socialist leadership, since they are the main obstacle standing in the way of this effort.


CovertAction Magazine is made possible by subscriptionsorders and donations from readers like you.

Blow the Whistle on U.S. Imperialism

 

Click the whistle and donate

 

When you donate to CovertAction Magazine, you are supporting investigative journalism. Your contributions go directly to supporting the development, production, editing, and dissemination of the Magazine.

CovertAction Magazine does not receive corporate or government sponsorship. Yet, we hold a steadfast commitment to providing compensation for writers, editorial and technical support. Your support helps facilitate this compensation as well as increase the caliber of this work.

Please make a donation by clicking on the donate logo above and enter the amount and your credit or debit card information.

CovertAction Institute, Inc. (CAI) is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization and your gift is tax-deductible for federal income purposes. CAI’s tax-exempt ID number is 87-2461683.

We sincerely thank you for your support.


Disclaimer: The contents of this article are the sole responsibility of the author(s). CovertAction Institute, Inc. (CAI), including its Board of Directors (BD), Editorial Board (EB), Advisory Board (AB), staff, volunteers and its projects (including CovertAction Magazine) are not responsible for any inaccurate or incorrect statement in this article. This article also does not necessarily represent the views the BD, the EB, the AB, staff, volunteers, or any members of its projects.

Differing viewpoints: CAM publishes articles with differing viewpoints in an effort to nurture vibrant debate and thoughtful critical analysis. Feel free to comment on the articles in the comment section and/or send your letters to the Editors, which we will publish in the Letters column.

Copyrighted Material: This web site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. As a not-for-profit charitable organization incorporated in the State of New York, we are making such material available in an effort to advance the understanding of humanity’s problems and hopefully to help find solutions for those problems. We believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. You can read more about ‘fair use’ and US Copyright Law at the Legal Information Institute of Cornell Law School.

Republishing: CovertAction Magazine (CAM) grants permission to cross-post CAM articles on not-for-profit community internet sites as long as the source is acknowledged together with a hyperlink to the original CovertAction Magazine article. Also, kindly let us know at info@CovertActionMagazine.com. For publication of CAM articles in print or other forms including commercial internet sites, contact: info@CovertActionMagazine.com.

By using this site, you agree to these terms above.


About the Author

18 COMMENTS

  1. Evelyn, Bruce was making a personal attack on me, not on Shuler. His comment was idiotic, especially since he gave absolutely no evidence for his attack on me.

  2. I think that is a wonderful idea but I’m really not adept at making websites , but you can check out the LEPAIO websites that has mine a other people’s talks about the relationship of the AFL-CIO with the CIA. The hyperlinks are in the article themselves.

    • Hello. I have a couple of questions. What does LEPAIO stand for? Also what wonderful idea are you referring
      to. I did not notice anybody suggesting an idea to you?

      • Labor Education Project on AFL-CIO International Operations. Check out the website. I was thanking one of the people who responded who suggested that I start a website in order to collect all the articles about Israel in one place. What did you think of the article?

        • I do not object to criticism of the policies of Israel’s government, but I am very proud of my Jewish heritage and I am not anti Zionist and I do not agree with most of your views. I have never heard of Histradut so I would have to study to learn more about this organization. You seem like a nice lady with good intentions, but to be honest I do not agree with most of your viewpoints. So of course I did not like this article.

          • Relative to the authentic Jewish law and religion – Zionism is a heresy, and a rebellion against G-d. It’s hard to be both, at the same time – no matter how you rationalize that. The Neturei Karta explain this the best… Rabbi Yisroel Dovid Weiss, for instance, explains that the history of Zionism (on their Youtube channel), is an atheistic, assimilationist movement, that hijacked the authentic Jewish Religion and law – bending it to the service of a Genocidal and Racist Ultra-Nationalism.

            Ironically it was, for a long time, a collaboration between these atheists and assimilationists in the Jewish community, and the anti-Jewish bigots of England and Europe, who just wanted the Jews to go elsewhere, and leave their countries, based upon mostly upon their prejudice and animus. Some however, are STILL just hoping to provoke an “End Times”/Armageddon scenario, which involves the world’s Jews returning to the Holy Land, so that Jesus cam return, and kill all who fail to convert.

            The Hagganah and Irgun were terrorists, by any definition of the word. Carol connects that to the hijacking of pro-labor sentiment, despite it being an apartheid and racist/ethnocentric vision of labor solidarity…like thinking of “Labor” in S. Africa – without thinking of the indigenous African population.

  3. Incisive and important piece on the complicity of labor in Israel settler colonial and apartheid rule and what is being done/can be done to resist! Thanks for writing this!

  4. Kudos on your expository work here Carol.

    It should be noted that Unions that SELL-OUT their memberships, to support Mandatory Human Medical Experimentation, without fully informed consent (which the Emergency Use Authorized, only, mRNA Gene Therapy injections, cleverly mislabeled as “Covid 19 Vaccines” – actually ARE) are already directly collaborating with fascism. Those mandates are Nuremberg Crimes, and medically contraindicated Mengele Medicine, at the population level.

    The plan to introduce these shots and mandates – under the guise of a(man-made, lab-created, deliberately released BioWeapon) Pandemic “Emergency” – predates the appearance of Covid 19. So too does the Agenda ID2020 omnibus digital identification, and “vaccine passport” – as the plan was announced no later than 2016. It turns out that these plans were accepted, in top down fashion by Quislings like Randi Weingarten, who, it turns out, is directly connected to the WEF – whose “Great Reset”/4th Industrial Revolution, will undoubtedly signal the end of organized labor, just as much as it does natural organic and free human beings…

    https://unlimitedhangout.com/2021/12/investigative-reports/how-education-international-is-pushing-teachers-unions-into-the-4th-industrial-revolution/

    As we see – both Weingarten and Shuler are a MOST one degree of separation from the heads of this fascist Empire. Note that in this list of instructions for the dottering and demented Emperor Biden – is a conversation with Shuler… https://youtu.be/aocn55pt4Vw

    And no – Joe Biden and his handler/cronies have no intention of holding the ZIONIST APARTHEID STATE accountable for the murder of Akleh, either…

          • When you thought Bruce was making a personal attack on Shuler you praised him. So you do not mind when people make personal attacks on people you dislike. It only bothers you if someone makes a personal attack on someone you like.

          • @Evelyn – I knew exactly what he was doing – but decided to use the ambiguity of his scurrilous remark, in order to reaffirm Carol’s worth, and Ms. Shuler’s perfidy, and imply that he was speaking honestly, and not just slandering a very talented and qualified author.

  5. I found this article of particular interest and importance since, in 1987, in the face of resistance on the part of the non-Palestinian leaders and influencers of the solidarity movement, for whom criticizing the Histadrut and the AFL-CIO were “off-limits” as was criticism of The Lobby, in general, Bay Area labor activist Steve Zeltzer and myself founded the Labor Com. on the Middle East with me becoming the editor of our almost quarterly journal, The Middle East Labor Bulletin, from 1988 to 1995. We focused on the actions of Palestinians as active individuals, as workers, as resisters, not simply as “victims” as has been the movement’s tendency, before and since. The MELB also carried unprecedented reporting on the activities of the Israel Lobby.

    We had union members from across the country subscribing to the MELB and taking actions among their own locals but the overall movement leadership, in disarray brought on to some degree by differences within the PLO, gave us little support even while we were organizing almost all of the Bay Area protests during the First Intifada. We also brought Palestinian unionists to the Bay Area and the Labor Notes conference in Detroit, Unfortunately, the MELB was published before the digital age so its contents were never uploaded to the internet.

    • Perhaps you could go back, and scan those articles, now – and then create a historical archive, for scholars, and members of the Anti-Zionist and Labor communities. Even if you only put them up on a website for a short time, you could then add them to something like Web dot Archive dot org or Archive dot org, to avoid incurring a longterm cost.

Leave a Reply